Overview
The preliminary July 2026 Italian bar-exam study estimates what access to legal practice changed for law graduates near the first-attempt 90-point cutoff. Barely passing raised eventual licensing by about 20 percentage points and produced an estimated €19,825 annual earnings advantage over years 2–23, roughly 50% for local compliers. The gain emerged after entry, concentrated in the upper tail, and came with greater volatility. The series compares risk, hours, signaling, and rents, then separates individual returns from system-wide policy effects.
Learning outcomes
- For marginal Italian law graduates near the first-attempt cutoff, legal-practice access raised estimated earnings by €19,825 a year over years 2–23, roughly 50%.
- The average gain was concentrated among upper-tail earners; licensed and non-licensed earnings distributions were nearly identical below the median.
- Legal practice brought substantially greater volatility, including an estimated 39% chance of an earnings decline of at least 5% versus about 10% for non-treated compliers.
- Risk compensation is the leading interpretation, not a proved identity; the hours, portable-signal, and competition tests each have limits.
Keywords
Preview every chapter · Unlock full text, audio, and video from chapter 4
PlansFAQ
What did the Italian bar-exam study actually estimate?
It estimated the causal earnings effect of gaining access to legal practice for law graduates near the first-attempt 90-point cutoff, not a universal return to any license.
Does the Italian bar exam guarantee a higher income?
No. The estimated average gain applies to local compliers, was concentrated in the upper tail, and came with greater volatility; it does not predict every lawyer’s earnings.
Why does the study favor risk compensation over monopoly rents?
Risk compensation fits the upper-tail gains and much higher volatility; the study finds little density effect on total legal revenue, though that test depends on demand assumptions and does not rule out every rent.
Can this evidence predict what removing licensing would do?
No. It estimates an individual access effect near an Italian exam cutoff, not the system-wide effects of changing supply, prices, service quality, or access to justice.